Mailbag: Is It Time for the Patriots to Part Ways with Jerod Mayo?
Should the Patriots Consider Parting Ways with Jerod Mayo? — Mike M.
It’s surprising to say, but the next three weeks will be critical for evaluating Jerod Mayo’s future with the Patriots. He should be coaching to secure his position. Generally, I oppose firing coaches after just one season, as it signals dysfunction within an organization — something the Patriots are dangerously close to embodying.
Last weekend’s game in Arizona was a disaster. Even after a bye week, the Patriots seemed unprepared, falling behind early, repeating familiar mistakes, and failing to remain competitive. The game was ugly, and Mayo’s postgame remarks were equally disappointing.
While media controversies often feel exaggerated, Mayo’s passive-aggressive jab at offensive coordinator Alex Van Pelt, saying, “You said it, not me,” was unprofessional. Criticizing play-calling publicly undermines his leadership, especially when he has the authority to overrule decisions. It’s Mayo’s team, and he must take accountability.
Personnel issues, particularly on the offensive line, are undeniable. The talent level is clearly lacking, which explains why Van Pelt’s consecutive runs inside the 5-yard line were ineffective. However, the defense—Mayo’s area of expertise—has regressed significantly. A Top 10 unit for three years, they’ve fallen to 21st in total defense, with an even worse DVOA ranking. Injuries are no longer a valid excuse, yet the team’s tackling and overall performance have deteriorated.
Mayo still has time to prove himself in the final games. He must demonstrate sharper decision-making and stronger leadership both on the sidelines and in media appearances. Otherwise, it may be time for the Patriots to seek new leadership in the offseason.
Who are the team’s vocal leaders? — Richard G.
There’s a noticeable lack of vocal leadership on the team, and it’s a major concern. Early injuries to captains David Andrews and Ja’Whaun Bentley, combined with Jabrill Peppers’ extended absence due to personal issues, left a leadership void. Among the initial captains, only Deatrich Wise, a quiet leader, and non-traditional leaders Joe Cardona (long snapper) and Jacoby Brissett (backup QB) remain.
Devin McCourty highlighted this issue, noting the absence of players who can rally the team and set a clear direction. As the Patriots look to build around Drake Maye for the future, identifying vocal leaders will be crucial.
Has Mayo shown any promise as a head coach? — Matt
Yes, though it feels like ages ago. The season opener against Cincinnati was well-executed, and Mayo’s controversial “soft” comment in London seemed to spark a brief turnaround. The team responded by winning two of their next three games, with the sole loss coming in overtime. However, consistency has been an issue.
Could Joe Milton III replace Jacoby Brissett as QB2? — Brett J.
It’s a fair question, but Mayo doesn’t appear eager to make that change. Last week, he stated that Jacoby remains the second quarterback, though he left room for adjustments if circumstances change.
Leave a Reply